Reinvention vs. Optimization
Your biggest constraint and opportunity can be found in either of two polar opposites of your business.
In 1991, the organizational theorist James G. March published a paper that has quietly shaped how we think about business ever since. He called it Exploration and Exploitation in Organizational Learning. His argument was simple but profound: every organization faces a tension between two forces — exploring the new and exploiting the known.
While this may sound dry and theoretical, this is one of those big ideas that can shift how you approach your business, or how you help clients transform their. At least it has for me. I must confess, I love theory (Confession: I read more than 1500 books during my career. Take that as humblebrag or pure madness). Despite this, I try to make my business about simple, practical business advice.
Exploration is the search for new possibilities, new markets, new models. It’s the restless curiosity that drives reinvention. Exploitation, on the other hand, is about refining what already works — optimizing, scaling, and making the machine run more efficiently.
If that sounds familiar, it should. It’s the same tension that lives inside every entrepreneur and leader I know: the desire to build the next thing while trying to keep the current thing from falling apart.
The problem, March warned, is that most organizations eventually lean too far toward exploitation. They become excellent at the wrong thing — optimizing a business model that the world has already moved past. It’s what consultants call “the success trap.” You get so good at operating your old playbook that you forget to question whether the game itself has changed.
In that sense, every company faces two fundamental challenges: reinvention and optimization.
Reinvention is the act of asking, “What business are we really in?” It’s the willingness to challenge your founding assumptions — the hypotheses, as Peter Drucker would say, on which your business was built. Maybe those assumptions were true once, but no longer. Maybe the client problem you built your agency or consultancy around has evolved. Maybe your pricing model — billing for time instead of outcomes — made sense a decade ago, but now it’s slowly eroding your margins and motivation.
Reinvention requires creative destruction. It means walking away from parts of your success, questioning your products, your positioning, even your identity. It’s dangerous work. It’s also the only thing that keeps a company alive in times of rapid change.
Optimization, by contrast, is the domain of discipline. It’s what happens once you know what game you’re playing and you want to win it consistently. Optimization is where you build systems, standardize processes, and engineer repeatability. It’s where profit lives. If reinvention is the artist, optimization is the engineer. One creates; the other refines.
The trick is knowing which mode you’re in — and whether you’ve overstayed your welcome there.
If you’re not where you want to be, the problem usually lies in one of these two camps. Either you’ve been optimizing too long — refining an outdated model, polishing an old identity, squeezing a lemon that’s lost its juice. Or you’ve been reinventing endlessly without focus — always experimenting, never consolidating, chasing the next shiny thing.
Reinvention without optimization is chaos. Optimization without reinvention is obsolescence.
The balance is different for every business. But the pace of change today, especially in the age of AI, has tilted the equation dramatically. The half-life of a business model has never been shorter. Technology has made exploitation easier — automation, analytics, dashboards — but it has also made reinvention more necessary. Because when the tools everyone uses become cheap and universal, differentiation comes not from what you optimize, but from what you reinvent.
For professional service firms, this is especially true. AI is swallowing much of the routine, the repetitive, the billable-hour work. The value has moved upstream — to thinking, imagination, and innovation. Reinvention now means questioning not just how you work, but what you sell, how you price it*,* and how you deliver it. The firms that thrive will move from selling time to selling outcomes. From projects to products. From services to systems.
Optimization still matters, of course. Once you’ve reinvented your model, you need to make it work. You need to build the operating system that lets you scale it predictably, profitably, and without chaos. That’s the work of design and discipline.
This is where my own practice has evolved: helping companies diagnose which problem they’re actually facing — a reinvention problem or an optimization problem — and guiding them through both. On the reinvention side, it’s about rediscovering relevance: defining new positioning, offers, and business models for the AI age. On the optimization side, it’s about building scalable, efficient systems — what I call SimpleOS™ and BrandOS™ — operating systems for clarity, growth, and focus.
Because the truth is, reinvention and optimization aren’t opposites; they’re seasons. You reinvent to stay alive. You optimize to stay profitable. And the art of modern leadership lies in knowing when to switch.
The world won’t slow down. The algorithms won’t stop learning. So our only real advantage — perhaps our only enduring one — is our capacity to learn faster than the environment changes.
Reinvention keeps you relevant. Optimization keeps you alive. The sweet spot, as James March might say, is where the two meet — where curiosity meets discipline, and exploration meets execution.
--
I help business owners and leaders Reinvent & Optimize their business. Almost without exception, companies need help with both. The current positioning, business model, and offerings need to be reinvented to catch up with the changing world (especially in the AI Age). And optimization means building an operating system that works (without the owner), then scaling it up.
Email for inquiries.